Years before we had Charley, when our relationship was at its very beginning, I was an apartment dweller who traveled frequently, so for pets I had two cats, Ben and Chloe. When they were 9 years old, the same summer Rob and I moved from being friends to something more, Chloe's kidneys started to fail. I nursed her along for a few months but finally it was time to let her go. After she was gone, Ben was inconsolable, yowling mournfully at the door of my apartment. To distract him from his misery, I went to the pound and got him a 12 week old kitten named Buck. Ben pretended at first to be aloof, but within weeks he and the kitten were inseparable.
When Charley came to us he was very young and a bundle of nervous energy. During the day he could hardly relax, jumping up at every sound or movement, following us wherever we went around the house, and of course chasing the cats. We had just moved into our house and old Ben had not weathered the move well, the third time he and I had moved in our life together. To protect them we quarantined the cats off into the back part of the house where the kids' bedrooms are and kept Charley with us on our side of the house so we could train him. I was deeply attached to Ben and not yet attached to Charley, and I resented the dog for separating me from Ben, who for nearly 15 years had been one of the few true constants in my life. For a couple of months Ben's health deteriorated and one day he walked up to me from under the bed where he had been hiding from the dog, climbed up into my lap, put his front paws on my chest and looked into my eyes. The next day I took him to the vet and let him go.
For a time after Ben left us Buck remained under the bed where he had kept vigil with Ben in his last weeks. I think he was mourning the cat who had raised him for nearly 6 years. Charley continued to be boisterous and restless, although glimpses of a sweet dog sometimes appeared. One day Bucky emerged from his hiding place in the bedroom, sauntered in to the living room without a care, jumped on the back of the couch and assumed the meatloaf position. Charley couldn't believe his good luck and ran over to give chase. To the complete surprise of all of us, Charley included, Bucky held his ground, reached out a paw and hit Charley on the flat part of the bridge of his nose several times fast, claws sheathed, making a hollow thunking sound. Charley was so astonished he just stood there blinking while Buck rained down these harmless blows on his nose. That was the turning point in my relationship with Charley, and Charley's with Buck. Ben's departure freed up space in my heart for Charley, and allowed Buck to assert some dominance in our make shift pack that Charley seemed to welcome. Charley began to calm down from that moment on, and Buck began to display much more personality than we had seen in him before.
Third way in which Charley made me a better person: love is not a zero-sum game, it is infinite. Sometimes you have to let go to see the new opportunities to love again.


